Cunningham v. Tomey Homma National Historic Event

Black and white historic portrait of a man
Tomekichi Homma, circa 1900
© Nikkei National Museum & Cultural Centre, Accession number: NNM 2013-55-4

Cunningham v. Tomey Homma legal battle was designated as a national historic event in 2011.

Historical importance: provided pre-Charter human rights activists with a compelling illustration of the need for measures that would protect the civil and human rights of individual Canadians.

Commemorative plaque: Japanese Fishermen’s Benevolent Society Building, Steveston Japanese Canadian Museum, 3811 Moncton Street, Steveston, British ColumbiaFootnote 1

Cunningham v. Tomey Homma

Prominent Japanese Canadian Tomekichi “Tomey” Homma fought a landmark legal battle in 1900–1903 against a provision of the British Columbia Provincial Elections Act, which barred Asian Canadians and First Nations from voting. While he won in the lower and superior courts, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council in England, then Canada’s highest court of appeal, upheld the Act, affirming the power of the provinces to disqualify voters on the basis of “race.” The injustice of this legal precedent inspired generations of activists who fought to secure equal voting rights for all Canadians, which was achieved only in 1960.

Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada
English plaque inscription

Cunningham v. Tomey Homma

In 1900-03, prominent Japanese Canadian Tomekichi “Tomey” Homma fought a landmark legal battle against a provision of the British Columbia Provincial Elections Act, which barred Asian Canadians and First Nations from voting. The 1903 decision of the highest court of appeal for Canada affirmed the power of the provinces to restrict voting eligibility on the basis of race. The injustice of this legal precedent provided Canada’s early human rights activists with a compelling illustration of the need for measures to protect the rights of individual Canadians. As a result, this important court case is considered a milestone in the development of human rights in Canada, and Homma has become a symbol of the movement.

Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada commemorative plaque for Cunningham v. Tomey Homma National Historic Event
Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada commemorative plaque for Cunningham v. Tomey Homma National Historic Event

In 1900, Homma, a Japanese immigrant and Canadian citizen (called naturalized British subjects before the 1947 Citizenship Act), applied to have his name entered on the voters’ list for the Vancouver electoral district. He was denied, an outcome that was anticipated because of an 1895 amendment to the Provincial Election Act that disqualified Japanese Canadians from the vote, along with First Nations, and Chinese Canadians (women were also excluded from the vote). Homma sued the registrar, Thomas Cunningham. At that time, no piece of legislation provided a safeguard against discrimination, therefore an individual’s only recourse was the courts where judges determined the validity of laws by interpreting the British North America (BNA) Act of 1867. Both the county court and the Supreme Court of British Columbia ruled in Homma’s favour; however, his victory was short-lived. In 1903, the highest court of appeal for Canada, the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council (JCPC) in London, England, ruled in favour of the province. The JCPC upheld the Provincial Elections Act, and declared that the BNA Act granted the provinces exclusive jurisdiction over civil rights, including the right to vote.

The JCPC’s decision had a lasting impact on Canadian federalism because it legally defined the vote as a privilege that a province could grant or withhold on the basis of race, from immigrant citizens or Canadian-born alike. It also validated in law a long tradition of racial, ethnic, class, and gender exclusions in Canada’s voting history. Moreover, it served as precedent in future legal challenges against anti-Asian legislation.

A commemorative plaque on a large rock in front of a building
The plaque for Cunningham v. Tomey Homma National Historic Event was installed at 3811 Moncton Street, Steveston, British Columbia.
A yellow and white building's facace with a commemorative plaque installed on a rock in front of it
The Japanese Fishermen’s Benevolent Society Building, Steveston Japanese Canadian Museum, Steveston, British Columbia

Tomekichi Homma’s legal battle is known as one of the most significant acts of resistance to repression in the history of human rights in Canada. Homma’s demand for equitable treatment influenced others to fight for equal rights, and, in retrospect, the court case has become crucial to our understanding of the context and events that led to the enactment of the Canadian Bill of Rights in 1960 and the entrenchment of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms into the Constitution Act of 1982. Equal voting rights for all Canadians was achieved only in 1960. While Tomekichi Homma did not live to see the enfranchisement of Japanese Canadians, his case marked the beginning of this protracted struggle for political and equal rights.

Backgrounder last update: 2017-12-04

The National Program of Historical Commemoration relies on the participation of Canadians in the identification of places, events and persons of national historic significance. Any member of the public can nominate a topic for consideration by the Historic Sites and Monuments Board of Canada.

Get information on how to participate in this process

Date modified :